Arch Manning, the highly anticipated quarterback prospect for the Texas Longhorns, is set to take over the starting role in the 2025 season following Quinn Ewers’ declaration for the NFL Draft. While Manning’s potential has garnered significant attention, some analysts remain skeptical about his readiness for the NFL.

College football analyst Aaron Murray recently expressed doubt about Manning’s status as a top NFL Draft pick. Murray questioned why Manning couldn’t surpass Ewers, who was drafted in the seventh round, if he were truly top-pick material. Despite Manning’s solid stats in 2024—939 passing yards, nine touchdowns, three interceptions, and a 67.8% completion rate—Murray remains unconvinced. He acknowledged Manning’s highlights but argued they don’t necessarily indicate first-round talent, emphasizing the need for more consistent performance before endorsing the hype.

Murray’s skepticism highlights the challenges Manning faces in transitioning from a backup role to a starting quarterback. While Manning has shown flashes of brilliance, his ability to perform consistently at a high level remains a question mark. The upcoming season will be crucial in determining whether Manning can live up to the lofty expectations set for him.

As Manning prepares for the 2025 season, all eyes will be on him to see if he can silence the doubters and prove that he is indeed a top-tier NFL prospect.